The three main structural problems with the senate in canada

Committees consider bills in detail and can make amendments. Officers of the Senate who are not members include the Clerk, the Deputy Clerk, the Law Clerk, and several other clerks.

This leads to occasional calls for reform, from elimination of the filibuster to the complete abolition of the institution.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper recently announced he would be asking the Supreme Court for its opinion on his plans for Senate reform.

He also wrote about the Condorcet paradoxwhich he called the intransitivity of majority preferences. Here too, I expect Duffy is not the only transgressor — which is why senators from both sides of the floor are so reluctant to address the question of residency.

When the debate concludes, the motion in question is put to a vote. Whenever a senator dies, resigns, is removed, or reaches the age limit, the sitting prime minister of Canada gets to appoint a replacement, meaning at any given time the Senate is a hodge-podge of various appointments dating back several different prime ministerial administrations.

Other cardinal systems include Proportional approval votingsequential proportional approval votingSatisfaction approval voting and majority judgment. Under the rules of the Senate, the Senate sits Mondays to Fridays. Independent applicants, not affiliated with any political party, will be approved by a new five-member advisory board to be in place by year enda reform that was intended to begin eliminating the partisan nature of the Senate.

Proportional systems[ edit ] Countries by type of proportional system Proportional representation is the most widely used electoral system for national legislatures, with the parliaments of over eighty countries elected by various forms of the system. Senate committees increasingly do the work the House can no longer do because of the bitter partisanship, permanent campaign mindset, and attendant unwillingness to do substantive policy work that characterizes the orientation of MPs.

In other countries there were calls for the restoration of plurality or majoritarian systems or their establishment where they have never been used; a referendum was held in Ecuador in on the adoption the two round system, but the idea was rejected.

Parliament of Canada, Senate website: This section does not cite any sources. A form of mixed-member proportional representation, Scorporowas used in Italy from until Most elections in the early history of democracy were held using plurality voting or some variant, but as an exception, the state of Venice in the 13th century adopted approval voting to elect their Great Council.

In most cases the second round is limited to the top two candidates from the first round, although in some elections more than two candidates may choose to contest the second round; in these cases the second round is decided by plurality voting.

Some provinces proposed that Senate appointments be turned over to the provincial governments. It is also used in 20 countries for electing the legislature. But turfing him from the upper house will not solve the problem.

Changes To The Canadian Senate

The Harper government argued that under the Constitution, abolition only requires the approval of Parliament plus seven provinces representing 50 per cent of Canada's population. And Senate committee reports are invariably regarded as far more objective, substantive and thorough than what comes from House committees.

There is a bigger story at play here. First, members in favour of the motion rise, so that the clerks may record their names and votes. The third electoral college elected 45 people, which were reduced to form a fourth electoral college of 11 by drawing lots.

One of the earliest recorded elections in Athens was a plurality vote that it was undesirable to win; in the process called ostracismvoters chose the citizen they most wanted to exile for ten years.

Party-list proportional representation is the single most common electoral system and is used by 80 countries, and involves voters voting for a list of candidates proposed by a party. Rewards — notably a Cabinet position or high-profile critic post — increasingly go to those who can score political points on their opponents, are camera friendly and satisfy geographic quotas, less so those who have public policy knowledge and the skills to work with their opponents to advance the public interest.

Electoral system

There were also seven vacancies. In parallel voting systems, which are used in 20 countries, [1] there are two methods by which members of a legislature are elected; part of the membership is elected by a plurality or majority vote in single-member constituencies and the other part by proportional representation.

Canada's Senate Problems: From Brazeau, To Duffy, To Zimmerberger

Many Liberal and independent former Liberal senators remained card-carrying members of the Liberal Party of Canada. And after getting within range of 60, will he or she be able to make the cross-party alliances to draw a handful of Northeastern or Midwestern Republicans out of the stance of massive resistance that they adopted in.

After becoming prime minister, Trudeau in appointed 22 new independent senators. Furthermore, the Parliament of Canada Act authorizes the Speaker to appoint another senator to take his or her place temporarily.

This is still largely the case today. The Senate cannot initiate money bills taxes or expenditures. And will he or she be able to be as creative as Reagan or Bush in recognizing that small and subtle institutional changes -- as simple as using a rule that.

Dual-member proportional representation is a proposed system with two candidates elected in each constituency, one with the most votes and one to ensure proportionality of the combined results. The Senate's purpose is to consider and revise legislation, investigate national issues, and most crucially according to the Constitution — give the regions of Canada an equal voice in Parliament.

The Senate is the Upper House of Canada's Parliament. "The structural change would probably have to come before there would be any significant change of attitude that this a relevant organization that is worth keeping." Canada's Senate Problems. Basic Problems with Non-Constitutional Senate Reform When it comes to the three main areas where reform is proposed - method of selecting senators, regional representation, and powers - the only one that can be achieved by non-constitutional means is the method of selecting Senators.

The official site of the Senate of Canada. Learn about the “Red Chamber” and keep track of senators’ work on bills, committee studies and current affairs. About the Senate The Senate is the Upper House in Canada’s bicameral parliamentary democracy.

It unites a diverse group of accomplished Canadians in service of. This takes two main forms; with voters allowed to give three preferences.

The other main form of majoritarian system is the two-round system, Similar problems in Belarus led to the parliamentary elections going to a fourth round of voting before enough parliamentarains were elected to make a quorum.

The three main structural problems with the senate in canada
Rated 0/5 based on 1 review
Changes To The Canadian Senate - Teaching Kids News